Min/Max Boards

Handbooks & Resources => Handbook Discussion => Topic started by: nijineko on March 21, 2012, 03:17:08 AM

Title: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on March 21, 2012, 03:17:08 AM
Please make suggestions for additions. Thank you.

Handbook (http://www.minmaxboards.com/index.php?topic=4099.new#new)
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 21, 2012, 12:00:29 PM
Thanks for putting this together.

These additions are from a list I got a long, long time ago, from someone named "Thugsb"

Blind-Fight (Corsair's Eyepatch, 3k, MIC) "grants you the benefit of the Blind-Fight feat for 1 min." Usable 3/day, Swift (also grants See Invisibility).

Bracers of the Blinding Strike: Bracers of armor +6; gain Improved Initiative feat, extra attack as if using a speed weapon 102,000 (Magic of Faerûn)
- since you draw a distinction, these give the "benefits" but not the feat. (MOF, pg155)

Maximize Spell on Conjuration(Healing) only - Armband of Maximized Healing, 1/dy, 7200gp, MOF, pg152
Maximize Spell on Healing spell - Armband of Maximized Healing, 3/dy, 7200gp, MIC-72, on healing spells of 6th level or lower

Run (Panther Mask (Gharyn's Monastic Array), 2,700, MIC-201) "provides you the benefits of the Run feat" - also gain +5' land speed in light or no armor (Dash feat?)

Track (Mask of the Tiger (Garb of the Hunting Cat), 4000, MIC-200) "grants you the benefits of the Track feat".  Also gain low-light vision.

Extra Music (Songblade, 6,400gp, CAdv-130) Only when wielded and only 1 extra bardic music/day (benefit, not feat)

Extra Spell (Pearl of Power, Lvl*Lvl*1,000, DMG) - benefit, not feat
Extra Slot (Memento Magicka, Lvl*Lvl*1,500, MIC-164) - benefit, not feat

Extra Turning (Nightstick, 7,500, Libris Mortis-78) - lets you turn/rebuke 4 more times per day (benefit, not feat)
Extra Turning (Reliquary Holy Symbol, 1000, MIC-120) Number of extra turn attempts given varies

Improved Sunder (Dragonfang Gauntlets, 8,610gp, MIC-95) 3 attacks/day

Metamagic — Reach Spell; Rod (MIC-165); 3 uses/day, cost varies

Metamagic Spell Trigger (Metamagic Wandgrip, 6000, CM)

Quickdraw (Eager weapon enhancement, +1 bonus, MIC-34)
Quickdraw (Crystal of Return (least), 300gp, MIC-65)
Sudden Extend (Aquamarine of Spell Extending, 3,700gp, PGtF)
Track and Scent (Headband of Pursuit, 15k, Secrets of Sarlona)
Uncanny Dodge (Warning Weapon, +1, MoF) - this is in my list of items that grant feats, but I think uncanny dodge is a class ability, not a feat.
Whirlwind Attack (Whirling weapon enhancement, +1, MIC-46) 3/day

Any Fighter Feat (Eternal/Wand of Heroics, 4420gp/4500gp, MIC) Either 2/day (so 60mins) or 50 charges - this is in my list of items that grant feats, but it should probably go under "spells"
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 21, 2012, 12:14:24 PM
A&EG, pg 139, lists some costs for adding things to intelligent items

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Garryl on March 21, 2012, 12:16:08 PM
All or almost all of the Bite of the Were-Whatever spells grant feats.

Mirror Move is a 3.0 spell (from a web enhancement, I think) that gives multiple Fighter feats (as long as you can watch someone who already has them). Similarly, the Feat Leech power lets you steal someone else's psionic feats.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 21, 2012, 12:33:01 PM
Just saw this in another thread

A feycraft light weapon lets you use DEX instead of STR just as if you has Weapon Finesse.  Not even magical, just a special property. (DMG2, pg275)
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Ziltoid on March 21, 2012, 12:54:05 PM
While they're not items, most Magical Locations do have a listed gp value for if you want to use them as treasure

IIRC there's already a handbook on old BG, but it hasn't been ported over.
Would it be an idea to include them?
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: snakeman830 on March 21, 2012, 01:23:34 PM
Two major things I need to point out:

1. Almost all (if not all) of the Metamagic rods in Complete Arcane were reprinted in MIC for much cheaper (that is, actually in line with the formulas used for the DMG metamagic rods instead of practically double that price).

2. The Precise weapon enhancement never references the Precise Shot feat in any way.  It merely removes the -4 penalty for shooting into melee.  It does NOT grant the benefit of Precise Shot, nor the feat itself, instead it gives an identical, numeric benefit.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 21, 2012, 05:32:28 PM
Hummm - I noticed they were reprinted, never noticed the drop in price.  Thanks!

Edit - there are 4 metamagic rods in the MIC.  One (Reach Spell) is brand new.  The other three are indeed about 1/2 price from their original listing.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 21, 2012, 05:56:58 PM
Updated metamagic rods

Metamagic — Chaining Spell; Rod (MIC-165); 3 uses/day, cost 14,000 / 54,000 / 121,500

Metamagic — Cooperation Spell; Rod (CAr-146); 3 uses/day, cost 2,700 / 10,500 / 24,300

Metamagic — Empower Spell; Rod (DMG-236); 3 uses/day, cost 9,000 / 32,500 / 73,000

Metamagic — Enlarge Spell; Rod (DMG-236); 3 uses/day, cost 3,000 / 11,000 / 24,500

Metamagic — Extend Spell; Rod (DMG-236); 3 uses/day, cost 3,000 / 11,000 / 24,500

Metamagic — Maximize Spell; Rod (DMG-236); 3 uses/day, cost 14,000 / 54,000 / 121,500

Metamagic — Piercing Cold; Rod of Piercing Cold: +2 frost dagger (Frostburn-111); 3 uses/day, cost 21,430 / 29,300 / 42,800.  If you subtract the cost of a +2 frost dagger (18,302), the remaining cost is 3,128 / 10,998 / 24, 498 which looking at other metamagic rods should be 3,000 / 11,000 / 24,500 for the Piercing Cold feat.

Metamagic — Quicken Spell; Rod (DMG-236); 3 uses/day, cost 35,000 / 75,500 / 170,000

Metamagic — Reach Spell; Rod (MIC-165); 3 uses/day, cost 9,000 / 32,500 / 73,000

Metamagic — Sculpting Spell; Rod (MIC-165); 3 uses/day, cost 3,000 / 11,000 / 24,500

Metamagic — Silent Spell; Rod (DMG-236); 3 uses/day, cost 3,000 / 11,000 / 24,500

Metamagic — Substitution Spell; Rod (MIC-165); 3 uses/day, cost 2,700 / 10,500 / 24, 300

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 21, 2012, 06:34:12 PM
Oh, what the hey.  I flipped through the Epic Level Handbook.  This is a 3.0 book, but I don't have the 3.5 version.

Leadership (Warlord's Breastplate, 416,200gp, ELH-129) "allows the wearer to attract and lead a number of followers
as if he had the Leadership feat", but no cohort

Incite Rage (Epic feat, Chaosbringer, 4,025,350gp  ELH-134) +6 greataxe of chaotic power

Improved Combat Reflexes (Everwhirling Chain, 5,220,325gp, ELH-134) +4 defending everdancing spiked chain of speed

Positive Energy Aura (Epic feat, Final Death, 3,580,308gp ELH-134) +5 undead dread ghost touch morning star - only gain feat if wielder can turn undead

Deflect Arrows and Infinite Deflection (Epic feat, Quarterstaff of Alacrity, 462,600gp, ELH-134) +5 quarterstaff of speed

Trample, Ride-By Attack, Sprited Charge (Horseshoes of the Peerless Steed, 217,000gp, ELH-146)


Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: awaken_D_M_golem on March 21, 2012, 06:44:31 PM
A&EG, pg 139, lists some costs for adding things to intelligent items
  • Combat Reflexes - +10,000gp
  • Blind-fight - +10,000gp
  • Improved Initiative - +10,000gp
  • Mobility - +10,000gp
  • Sunder - +10,000gp
  • Expertise - +10,000gp
Ninja'd.

... getting 10 Ranks is better than +5 Skill Points from the Open Minded feat.
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/magicItems/intelligentItems.htm

Psychic Reformation level 4 psi power ... deserves special mention, for what to do with those feat slots.

Dark Chaos Feat Shuffle ... also deserves special mention.



edit --- the 504 Feats build thread, was somehow not lost to all the wotc board changeovers.
http://community.wizards.com/go/thread/view/75882/19866566/The_True_Dilettante_-_New_Feat_Record_-_504_feats?pg=1

Very juicey.

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 21, 2012, 06:54:07 PM
... getting 10 Ranks is better than +5 Skill Points from the Open Minded feat.

Be careful here.  The ITEM has 10 ranks.  It doesn't add +10 to whatever the wielder has.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 21, 2012, 07:00:33 PM
From reading these, I don't know if these give the feat, or just the benefits of the feat.

Scorpion’s Resolve and Scorpion’s Sense (Scorpion Carapace, +32,000gp, Sandstorm-130) "The wearer gains the benefit of the Scorpion’s Resolve and Scorpion’s Sense feats" - special ability that can be added to armor

Sandskimmer (Sandstriding Ring, 5000gp, Sandstorm-132) "The wearer gains the benefit of the Sandskimmer feat"

Sand Camouflage (Cape of the Wastes, 30,000gp, Sandstorm-133) "Finally, the wearer gains the benefit of the Sand Camouflage feat"
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 21, 2012, 07:20:14 PM
You should add a "Misc" to your handbook.  Someone already mentioned the Dark Chaos Feat Shuffle.  The Chameleon floating feat at 2nd level should also be mentioned.

The Stronghold Builder's Guide (pg 32) mentions a Training Area, Combat.  If you use the rules for training for feats in the DMG, has some benefits.  Can get the same benefits from a Training Area, Rogue.

Plane of Shadow Traits (Stronghold Builder's Guide, pg 122) - on the plane of shadow, spells with the shadow descriptor are cast is if prepared with the Maximize Spell feat, though they don't require a higher level spell slot.

Plane of Fire Traits (Stronghold-124) - on the plane of fire, spells and SLAs with the fire descriptor are both maximized and enlarged (at the relevant feats), but don't use higher slots

Astral Plane Traits (Stronghold-127) - all spells and SLAs may be employed as if improved by the Quicken Spell feat, but don't use higher slots

Plane of Water Traits (Stronghold-128) - spells and SLAs with the water descriptor are both extended and enlarged (at the relevant feats), but don't use higher slots.

Guess you should add a "Locations" section too :)

Another for misc:

Aptitude Weapon (ToB-148, +1 bonus) - lets you use feats for a particular type of weapon (eg Weapon Focus) with the aptitude weapon, even if it's a different type.







Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on March 22, 2012, 01:30:20 AM
first, thank you all for your additions and comments. i had found some of the sources you mention, and had not gotten around to adding them yet. but i also see new suggestions. thank you.

now, some comments on my part:

extra spell does not duplicate or grant benefit of a feat. the function is slightly different. it functions more like a certain spell.

items which do not state "grants feat" or "grants benefit of a feat" in at least a variant of that wording in the description will go in the "otherwise" section.

if an item does not grant a feat, but only a class ability, it does not "technically" go here. if there is a list of class ability duplicating items, it would be a worthy addition in a second post in the handbook thread.

can someone list all the bite/were spells and the feats granted, please? never mind, found it. =D

someone please quote me the dark chaos shuffle? i do not have that source.

it is incorrect to state that the precise weapon ability never references the precise shot feat in any way. it does in fact reference it. namely they don't stack. thus i feel this falls into the category of "grants benefit".

mirror move source, anyone? found that, too. same source as bite spells, in fact.



okay it is late, and i have only gotten through some of your posts. i will catch up later. thanks again for the info, everyone!
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: snakeman830 on March 22, 2012, 09:53:01 AM
Quote from: MIC
Precise
Price: +1 bonus
Property: Ranged weapon
Caster Level: 5th
Aura: Faint; (DC17) evocation
Activation:--

You can shoot or throw a precise weapon at an opponent engaged in melee without incurring the standard -4 penalty.  This benefit does not apply if you already have the Precise Shot feat.
It doesn't say it "grants" or gives "the benefit of" the feat at all.  The reason it doesn't apply if you have Precise Shot is because the feat removes the penalty, so this property no longer has anything to do (since it only removes a penalty and does not grant a bonus).  It is pretty clear on this.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Garryl on March 22, 2012, 10:21:43 AM
can someone list all the bite/were spells and the feats granted, please? never mind, found it. =D

Note that the Bite of Were-x spells were reprinted in Spell Compendium (mostly untouched, I think, except a generally level lower).
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 22, 2012, 11:56:17 AM
Various spells and domains from the spell compendium

Bite of the Werebear (SpC-28) - gain benefits of the Blind-Fight and Power Attack Feats, Dur 1r/lvl
Bite of the Wereboar (SpC-28) - gain benefit of the Blind-Fight feat, Dur 1r/lvl
Bite of the Wererat (SpC-28) - gain benefit of the Weapon Finesse feat, Dur 1r/lvl
Bite of the Weretiger (SpC-28) - gain benefits of the Blind-Fight and Power Attack feats, Dur 1r/lvl
Bite of the Werewolf (SpC-29) - gain benefit of the Blind-Fight feat, Dur 1r/lvl

Dolorous Blow (SpC-70) - doubles crit range (like the Improved Critical feat); also auto-confirms crits; Dur 1 min/lvl
Favor of the Martyr (SpC-89) - gain benefits of Endurance feat; Dur 1min/lvl
Heroics (SpC-113) - any fighter feat, but must meet pre-reqs for that feat; Dur 10min/lvl
Nightstalker's Transformation (SpC-148) - Weapon Finesse; Dur 1r/lvl
Spikes (SpC-202) - doubles threat range (like Improved Crit)
Strategic Charge (SpC-210) - gain benefit of Mobility feat; Dur 1r/lvl

Weapon of Impact (SpC-237) - double threat range (like Improved Crit), bludgeoning weapon only; Dur 10min/lvl (basically Keen for bludgeoning weapons)

--------

Domains to go with the Domain Draught

Skill Focus(Craft Skill of your choice) - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Craft Domain (SpC-272)
Blind-Fight - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Darkness Domain (SpC-272)
Spell Focus (enchantment) - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Domination Domain (SpC-273)
Lightning Reflexes - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Drow Domain (SpC-273)
Great Fortitude - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Dwarf Domain (SpC-274)
Point Blank Shot - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Elf Domain (SpC-273)
Martial Weapon Proficiency and Weapon Focus for light hammer or warhammer (your choice) - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Metal Domain (Spc-276)
Extend Spell - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Planning Domain (SpC-278)
Scribe Scroll - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Rune Domain (SpC-279)
Improved Initiative - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Time Domain (SpC-281)
Extra Turning - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Undeath Domain (SpC-281)
Skill Focus (Appraise) - Domain Draught (MIC-156, 3300gp) - Wealth Domain (SpC-281)
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 22, 2012, 01:56:46 PM
Quote
Any Metamagic Spell Trigger (Metamagic Wandgrip, 6000, CM) Allows effects of metamagic feats to be applied to a spell trigger item.

I think this is a poorly worded.  It doesn't duplicate the effect of any metamagic feat.  It duplicates the effects of one specific feat, namely the Metamagic Spell Trigger feat (CM-45), which itself applies to other metamagic feats (using charges instead of changing the spell level).  The Wandgrip also applies only to wands, not any spell trigger item (unlike the feat itself, which does apply to any spell trigger item).

I suggest:

Metamagic Spell Trigger 6000gp cost
Metamagic Wandgrip; usable only with wands (CM-133)

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 22, 2012, 02:26:20 PM
Spells

Towering Thunderhead (CM-120) - Any sonic or electricity spell of 7th level or lower cast within a towering thunderhead is automatically empowered (as if affected by the Empower Spell feat); Dur 3 rounds (of towering thunderhead, not of other spells cast)

---

Items that duplicate effects of a feat  (these are all optional spell components)

Extend Spell 100 gp * spell level cost
Angel Down (CM-135), abjuration spell only, used as additional material component

Heighten Spell 150 gp * original spell level cost
Devil's eye (CM-135), heightens only 1 level, divination spell only, used as additional material component

Heighten Spell 200 gp * original spell level cost
Dragon's Tear (CM-136), heightens only 1 level, fire or mind-affecting spell only, used as additional material component

Widen Spell 200 gp * spell level cost
Fairy Button (CM-136), illusion spell only, used as additional material component

Extend Spell 100 gp * spell level cost
Fairy Dust (CM-136), transmutation spell only, used as additional material component

Rapid Spell 300 gp * spell level cost
Golden Desert Honey (CM-136), summoning spells with a casting time of 1 round only, used as additional material component

Extend Spell 100 gp * spell level cost
Possibility Dust (CM-136), creation spell only, used as additional material component

Extend Spell 120 gp * spell level cost
Serpents' Tongue (CM-136), enchantment spell only, used as additional material component

Widen Spell 200 gp * spell level cost
Singing Shell (CM-136), spells with sonic descriptor only, used as additional material component

Enlarge Spell 200 gp * spell level cost
Singing Shell (CM-136), spells with sonic descriptor that don't affect an area only, used as additional material component

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 22, 2012, 03:31:56 PM
Gain benefit of feat

Far Shot
Bow of Elvenkind (14,700gp, CC-137); +1 composite longbow, automatically adjusts to Str of any elf who uses it; more for clerics of Corellon Larethian); if used with arrows from a Quiver of Elvenkind (DMG), gain the benefit of the Far Shot Feat

Duplicate feat

Empower Spell
Rod of Fury (CAr-145) 1/day, spell of 6th level or lower; also gives deflection bonus to AC; price varies based on AC bonus: 26,800 gp (+1), 38,800 gp (+2), 58,800 gp (+3), 77,600 gp (+4), 95,600 gp (+5).

Quicken Spell 215gp cost
Aurial Sapphire (CC-131); air domain or spell with air descriptor only; used as optional material component

Quicken Spell 225gp cost
Pearl of the Waves (CC-132); water domain or spell with water water descriptor only; used as optional material component

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Garryl on March 22, 2012, 03:48:00 PM
The rod of fury's 1/day empower looks like it costs 22.8k on its own. The prices make perfect sense if you treat the price multiplier on the cheaper of any additional effects in an item as x2 instead of x1.5.

26,800 - 2x  2,000 = 22,800
38,800 - 2x  8,000 = 22,800
58,800 - 2x18,000 = 22,800
(77,600 - 32,000)/2 = 22,800
(95,600 - 50,000)/2 = 22,800
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 22, 2012, 05:12:06 PM
That makes sense.  I couldn't figure it out myself.

And the pricing seems ok, when you compare it against a metamagic rod @ 6th level, which costs 32,500gp for 3/dy.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 22, 2012, 05:52:02 PM
Item that Gives Feat

Improved Counterspelling 132,000gp cost
Rod of Reversal (CDiv-100); also turn next nine levels of spells like Spell Turning; requires True Believer feat or sacrifice 8th-level divine spell slot

Spell that gives feat

Spring Attack
Divine Agility (CDiv-162); dur 1r/lvl

Item that Duplicates Feats

Maximize Spell 33,600gp cost
Gauntlets of the Blood-Lord (CDiv-97); touch spells only; also grant +4 luck bonus to-hit on touch attacks; requires True Believer Feat or 6th-level divine spell slot

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: awaken_D_M_golem on March 23, 2012, 04:23:06 PM
Good stuff Kitep.


Quote from: ~ftm3/JHtB
    Most of the deconstruction of item costs to extract the price for feats is straightforward by following the cost tables. By looking at several items I determined (with reasonable confidence, I think) that WotC figures the cost for a single save bonus (such as Reflex) is 1/3 the cost of a resistance bonus to all three saves. (When added to an item with other features, such as a granted feat, remember the 1.5x cost multiplier for an additional property.)

Hey, PLZ and Bastian have that massive cost reduction thread over here,
http://www.minmaxboards.com/index.php?topic=1000

So even if a "deconstructed" price can't be figured out ...
Personally I like it, but iirc there was some debate a long time ago, against deconstruction.
Of course this becomes a triple scoop of CO ice cream.
 :)
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on March 26, 2012, 12:45:46 AM
awesome suggestions, corrections, and recommendations, everyone. thank you. i do not have time to edit tonight, but i will be back at it.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Endarire on March 26, 2012, 07:35:43 PM
You have a very big space between section headings and the following text.  Pweath remove this.

Also, bold all item names, like Metamagic rods.

And what do you mean by "Binding" feats?  Did you mean "Buying?"

Still quite handy!
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Thurbane on March 26, 2012, 09:16:18 PM
Gain benefit of feat

Danger Sense
Ring of Anticipation (DotU, 8000gp); allows you to roll twice for Initiative and take the best result - unlike the feat (1/day), this functions continuously.

Extra Spell
Knowstones (Dragon #333, spell level squared * 1000gp) add an additional spell known to spontaneous casters with a limited Spells Known list (Sorcerer, Bard, Favored Soul etc.)



Ring of Anticipation (Drow of the Underdark) gives a vastly superior version of the Danger Sense (MH/CAd) feat (ring is continuous, all day long; the feat is 1/day).

Also, Knowstones (Dragon, not sure of issue #) are basically Extra Spell for a spontaneous caster.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Endarire on March 26, 2012, 09:57:11 PM
See also here (http://www.minmaxboards.com/index.php?topic=3797.0;topicseen).
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 31, 2012, 10:14:40 PM
Some more:

Grants Feat

Improved Sunder (Breaking Blade, 18,310gp, AEG-103) +2 halberd; does double damage against simple and martial reach weapons

Ambidexterity (a 3.0-only feat) and Two-Weapon Fighting (Rod of Seven Parts, artifact, AEG-154) only when wielding 6 or 7 parts of the rod

Grants benefit of:

Deflect Arrows (Arrowdeath Flail, 33,690gp, AEG-99) +2/+1 dire flail; weilder can deflect projectiles and thrown weapons as if she had the Deflect Arrows feat; when taking total defense action, grants an additional +2 deflection AC to ranged weapon attacks only

Two-Weapon Fighting (Rod of Flailing, 50,000gp, DMG-235) +3 dire flail; 1/day get +4 deflection AC and +4 resistance saves for 10 minutes

Augment Summoning (Deep Hollow Circle, 50,000gp, Races of Stone-168) dwarf or gnome only (or UMD DC25 to emulate race); also summons additional Earth sub-type creature

Quicken Spell (Dwarfheim Circle, 50,000gp, Races of Stone-168) dwarf only (or UMD DC25 to emulate race); works on spontaneous spells as well; also works on spell-like abilities

Maximize Spell (Healing Circle, 50,000gp, Races of Stone-169) Conjuration (healing) spells only

Duplicate Feats:

Improved Crit - Impact (MIC-37) +1 weapon bonus, doubles threat range on bludgeoning weapon (ie Keen for bludgeon)

Empowered Spellshard (MIC-96); acts like Empower Spell on a specific spell; 3x/day; cost: 1500gp (1st level spell), 3000gp (2nd level spell), 6000gp (3rd level spell)


Deflect Arrow (Buckler, Beetle, AEG-14) Beetle blocks ranged attacks as the Deflect Arrows feat, but uses the beetle's reflex save(+6) not your own; must be worn for a day before it works.

Improved Disarm (Disarmor Armor, 10,875gp, AEG-94) 3/day, when opponent scores a melee hit, wearer can attempt a disarm with a +5 bonus; +2 scale mail (subtract cost of +2 scale mail (4,200gp), and 3/dy improved disarm costs 6,675gp)
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: sirpercival on April 02, 2012, 10:52:12 AM
Illusion Bane (+1 weapon enhancement) lets you ignore concealment effects from illusion spells (a la Pierce Magical Concealment).
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on April 02, 2012, 11:33:36 PM
A couple more from BOED & BOVD

Gains feat

Spell Focus (Good), Gift of Faith, Nimbus of Light, and Word of Creation feats - Regalia of Good, artifacts, BOED-119 - must possess 2 out of 3 items

Lichloved, Dark Speech, Evil Brand, Verminfriend - Regalia of Evil, artifacts, BOVD-122 - must possess 2 out of 3 items

Give benefits

Endurance - Second Wind spell (BOED-106) dur 1hr/lvl

Dark Speech - Elixir of the Dark Speech, 750gp, BOVD-114
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on April 05, 2012, 01:18:58 AM
Updated main thread with material through "reply #17", except for the domain draughts, which are next to be added. Anyone recall if domain abilities grant feat, grant benefit, or other wording, by chance?

Also noticed the request for better formatting. How are the results so far? I added lists wherever there is more than one item under a given feat. Suggestions?

And thank you for all the posts! I may be slow, but I will get through all the additions.


and in answer to the question i caught as i skimmed all the additions: the main title is a play on the term feet binding, or foot binding... a practice of questionable merits. but it is mainly a simple eye catching pun. ^^


as background, i actually started this thread as a result of trying to help a friend of mine with whom i have an ongoing debate concerning which is better, a tempest or a dervish... we have decided to have a contest adjudicated by a third party and are building characters to take our argument of tempest vs dervish into the arena of mortal character combat to settle our differences. he was rather feat starved in his build, so i was looking up ways to get around it for him. and then i thought that the resulting list of how to get feats i was making would be great reference material for everyone, and here we all are.   :D
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on April 05, 2012, 11:43:25 AM
Anyone recall if domain abilities grant feat, grant benefit, or other wording, by chance?

They're bonus feats.  At least the ones in the SpC.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on April 06, 2012, 09:05:06 PM
someone please quote me the dark chaos shuffle? i do not have that source.

Dark Chaos Feat Shuffle, aka DCFS

It depends on 2 spells in the Fiendish Codex 1 - Hordes of the Abyss

Embrace the Dark Chaos (Fiendish Codex 1 - pg 92) - replace 1 feat you know with an Abyssal heritor feat - Cleric 8, Wiz 8, 250 xp, instantaneous

Shun the Dark Chaos (Fiendish Codex 1 - pg 95) - replace 1 Abyssal heritor feat with any other feat you qualify for - Cleric 8, Wiz 8, 250 xp, instantaneous

So you embrace, then shun, and voila!, you've shuffled one feat for another.  It also involves gaining "taint" (toward Chaos, not evil), which may or may not be important in a campaign.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: snakeman830 on April 07, 2012, 12:41:52 AM
Not really.  Your alignment only shifts if you have 2 Abyssal Heritor feats (unless you take the Ordered Chaos feat)
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on March 25, 2013, 09:10:11 AM
Saw this in another thread

Quote from: Matt Mons
Manual of the winding way (Dungeon 117, p78) can permanently give dodge, mobility, or spring attack to the reader, but it's an artifact.


Can it be added to the handbook?

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on March 25, 2013, 05:23:18 PM
Saw this in another thread

Quote from: Matt Mons
Manual of the winding way (Dungeon 117, p78) can permanently give dodge, mobility, or spring attack to the reader, but it's an artifact.


Can it be added to the handbook?

updated handbook with entries through post 19, plus requested item above.

also spent a few hours attempting to clean up and harmonize entry style. well... at least it looks a lot better now.

^^


for those who are curious, and at least one commented about it above, the title is an intentional pun on the practice of feet binding - an example of the extreme lengths to which real life optimizers will go to achieve an effect.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Mithril Leaf on March 26, 2013, 09:15:07 PM
Soul Tick from Fiend Folio automatically empowers all your evil spells. Touch of the Blackened Soul from Dragon Magic makes all your spells evil for 3 rounds. And has a duration of personal.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: snakeman830 on April 19, 2013, 05:57:02 PM
Serpent Armor got updated in MIC to be +1 leather armor with a +1 resistance bonus on Reflex saves for 12,160gp.  Combat Reflexes is still granted.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on May 05, 2013, 07:23:13 PM
Another item(s) to add

Any elf or cleric of Corellon Larethian who uses a Bow of Elvenkind (Comp Champion, p137) with arrows from a Quiver of Elvenkind (Comp Champion, p144) gains the benefit of the Far Shot feat.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Phoenix00 on May 31, 2013, 06:12:25 PM
I do not know what books this was originally from but on wizards website they have a pdf called new magic items, and some of these items grant feats.  (it appears 3.0 since it references polymorph self)

http://www.wizards.com/dnd/files/MagicItems.pdf

Mantle of Rage 6,000 gp.  Rage as a 1st level barbarian or if you have the rage feature rage 1 additional times per day (this is similar to the feat extra rage but 1/day instead of 2)
Reflex Weapon (equivalent to a +1), gain the benefits of combat reflexes.

There are other goodies such as scrying at will for only 42,000 gp but those aren't feat related
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on May 31, 2013, 11:21:57 PM
I do not know what books this was originally from but on wizards website they have a pdf called new magic items, and some of these items grant feats.  (it appears 3.0 since it references polymorph self)

http://www.wizards.com/dnd/files/MagicItems.pdf

Mantle of Rage 6,000 gp.  Rage as a 1st level barbarian or if you have the rage feature rage 1 additional times per day (this is similar to the feat extra rage but 1/day instead of 2)
Reflex Weapon (equivalent to a +1), gain the benefits of combat reflexes.

There are other goodies such as scrying at will for only 42,000 gp but those aren't feat related

Thank you very much. It also appears that I missed not only that specific pdf in my archive, but also about 5 other related articles. I will be adding them to my master site archive.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Sleepyphoenixx on August 30, 2013, 02:27:03 PM
Nimblestep (18310gp, LEoF p. 152) is a +1 Short Sword that grants Up the Walls and lets you focus as a move action (effectively Psionic Meditation).
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: awaken_D_M_golem on August 30, 2013, 03:14:27 PM
Wow that's a good one for any psi to have.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: phaedrusxy on August 30, 2013, 03:20:16 PM
Nimblestep (18310gp, LEoF p. 152) is a +1 Short Sword that grants Up the Walls and lets you focus as a move action (effectively Psionic Meditation).
Wow that's a good one for any psi to have.

Indeed... Two decent feats, one of which is basically a "must have" for most psionic characters.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: awaken_D_M_golem on September 20, 2013, 05:12:43 PM
Quote: Niji
"Any
    Mirror Move (WOTC website archive, Retired section, Spellbook articles) limited to "general feats with obvious physical effects" within a limited time. "

Link ---> http://www.wizards.com/dnd/article.asp?x=dnd/sb/sb20000901a


Custom Item goes: 2 * 3 * (1800 or 2000) = 10 800 gp or 12 000 gp , for INT # of feats.
Cheap, and can be much cheaper.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Gazzien on November 11, 2013, 09:40:55 PM
Domination Domain Draught should be listed as Spell Focus (Enchantment) only.

Unless I'm mistaken, and a different Domination Domain grants Spell Focus (Any)?
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Arz on February 26, 2014, 06:48:08 PM
Caster's Shield - Scribe Scroll - any spellcaster can ,not, any spellcaster with the scribe scroll feat.

Gremma's Cauldron - Brew Potion - EtU p217
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Gazzien on March 05, 2014, 09:46:11 AM
http://www.wizards.com/dnd/article.asp?x=dnd/mc/mc20020130a

Griffon lance of Goring grants Spirited Charge
Silverhelm of the Guardian grants Improved Initiative
Silver Sickles of Soranth (x2) grant Ambidexterity and Two-Weapon Fighting
Writhing Asps of Sss'thasine'ss (minor artifact) permanently gives Snake Blood

Grants = effects of
The artifact actually gives you the feat.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: phaedrusxy on March 05, 2014, 02:39:34 PM
Nice find on Spirited Charge! It's expensive, but basically saves you three feats!
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on June 09, 2014, 09:13:24 PM
Gauntlets of the Blood-Lord (CDiv-97) - effects of Maximize Spell on any touch spell w/o increase in level
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Lokiyn on February 21, 2015, 09:30:45 PM
http://archive.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/we/20060526a

Quote
Special: A character who meets the prerequisites automatically gains Ritual Transference as a bonus feat after constructing five talismans of transference.

In short you can buy feats to reform / retrain / Dark Shuffle at the cost of 5 talismans.

Once you change the feat i can't see anything that prevents you from making another 5 talismans and regaining the feat.

In essence, for roughly 5 days labor, 500 gp, and 80xp; you can "buy" feat slots.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: PlzBreakMyCampaign on July 16, 2015, 12:57:29 AM
Not to blow everyone's mind here, but there is a 3.0 rule that states that items that give a benefit of a feat qualify you for having the feat for other prereq things [PrCs, other feats, etc]. It's late, so I'm not going to dig up which 3.0 book it was.

So unless a later book updated that, it still stands.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on July 17, 2015, 10:34:00 PM
Not to blow everyone's mind here, but there is a 3.0 rule that states that items that give a benefit of a feat qualify you for having the feat for other prereq things. It's late, so I'm not going to dig up which 3.0 book it was.

So unless a later book updated that, it still stands.

yeah, that's always been valid in 3.5. lose the object, lose access to the feat chain, however, but there's never been a problem the prereq thing.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Jowgen on August 05, 2015, 10:51:51 AM
Hi there. I made a list of similar things (using slightly different qualifying criteria I think) over on giantitp, which draws on your guide (credit is given, no worries). I considered copying it over here, but seeing how you're still active and this isn't really my "turf"; I thought it prudent to just link you to my list so that you can add stuff from it to yours if you feel like it. So yeah here ya go.  :)

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showthread.php?400840-List-of-Feat-Granting-Items-Locations-Grafts
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on August 06, 2015, 12:00:21 AM
Hi there. I made a list of similar things (using slightly different qualifying criteria I think) over on giantitp, which draws on your guide (credit is given, no worries). I considered copying it over here, but seeing how you're still active and this isn't really my "turf"; I thought it prudent to just link you to my list so that you can add stuff from it to yours if you feel like it. So yeah here ya go.  :)

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showthread.php?400840-List-of-Feat-Granting-Items-Locations-Grafts

Thank you.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Jowgen on August 09, 2015, 05:42:41 AM
No problem. Also, didn't include it on my  list, but you may want to: Fingerbone Necklace, Savage Species 56; Mounted Combat (goblinoid only).
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Kethrian on December 10, 2015, 09:43:51 AM
I took a closer look at the Staff of Mighty Sweeping.  Its price is 28,600gp.  That's 10,000gp more than a +3 weapon, making the staff likely priced out as a double weapon, with 14,000gp for a +2 and Mighty Sweeping on each end.  That would place Mighty Sweeping at 6,000gp as a WSA.  Or, if it really was priced for a single end, then the price for just that enchantment would be 20,000gp.  I'd be inclined to believe the former is correct, given that the staff was MWed properly as a double weapon already.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Necrosnoop110 on December 10, 2015, 09:59:35 AM
Quote
Feats. Let's face it, feats are at a premium. Many characters never receive more than 7 feats in their career. Wizards get a few more. Fighters get even more, but they usually are hard pressed to do everything they want to, unless the follow one of the "optimized paths". Flaws might net you another one or two, but depend on a generous DM.

Typo? Shouldn't it be: Fighters get even more, but they usually are hard pressed to do everything they want to, unless they follow one of the "optimized paths".
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: awaken_D_M_golem on December 10, 2015, 05:53:46 PM
I took a closer look at the Staff of Mighty Sweeping.  Its price is 28,600gp.  That's 10,000gp more than a +3 weapon, making the staff likely priced out as a double weapon, with 14,000gp for a +2 and Mighty Sweeping on each end.  That would place Mighty Sweeping at 6,000gp as a WSA.  Or, if it really was priced for a single end, then the price for just that enchantment would be 20,000gp.  I'd be inclined to believe the former is correct, given that the staff was MWed properly as a double weapon already.

Ahh, CaptnQ did a whole lot of reverse engineering on his EVD series.
Maybe he didn't get all of the details on this one (idk).
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on December 11, 2015, 10:13:39 AM
I took a closer look at the Staff of Mighty Sweeping.  Its price is 28,600gp.  That's 10,000gp more than a +3 weapon, making the staff likely priced out as a double weapon, with 14,000gp for a +2 and Mighty Sweeping on each end.  That would place Mighty Sweeping at 6,000gp as a WSA.  Or, if it really was priced for a single end, then the price for just that enchantment would be 20,000gp.  I'd be inclined to believe the former is correct, given that the staff was MWed properly as a double weapon already.

I don't quite understand where you get the 14,000gp at.  But I think the real problem is that you read "mighty sweeping" as one thing, and it's really two things:  "mighty" and "sweeping".

Magic of Faerun, p145
Quote
Staff of Mighty Sweeping: This sturdy ash +2 sweeping quarterstaff also grants the wielder the Improved Trip feat.

Magic of Faerun, p141
Quote
Sweeping: This property grants a +4 bonus on any Strength checks the wielder makes as part of an attempt to trip an opponent with the weapon.   Caster Level: 5th; Prerequisites: Craft Magic Arms and Armor, bull’s strength; Market Price: +1 bonus.

So "+2 sweeping" makes it equivalent to a +3 weapon, which as you point out is 18,000gp.  If used on both ends, it would cost double, or 36,000, which is more that what the staff costs.  The "mighty" adjective is just fluff that refers to the granted feat (Improved Trip), which seems to cost an extra 10,000.  Arms and Equipment guide says extra feats usually cost 5-10K, so that fits right in.

It can be confusing, but I think the book just forgot to double the price for a putting an enchantment on both ends, though it did remember to double it for masterwork quality.

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Endarire on December 11, 2015, 05:31:40 PM
Complete Shopping List (http://dictummortuum.blogspot.com/2011/12/complete-shopping-list.html)

This page has a list of feats and the effects of feats granted by items.  I'm just dropping this link in here quickly.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: PlzBreakMyCampaign on June 06, 2016, 01:18:08 PM
I know this was old, but I was curious if I could get this put into xls so I can simply sort it based off parameters such as lowest maginal cost (for the feat) and lowest total costs (for the whole item). What are the odds that you want to do that, nin?
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on July 18, 2016, 10:49:45 AM
I know this was old, but I was curious if I could get this put into xls so I can simply sort it based off parameters such as lowest maginal cost (for the feat) and lowest total costs (for the whole item). What are the odds that you want to do that, nin?

i could be bribed into it, certainly. ^^

i've been meaning to get back to this thread and finish off all the suggested edits, at the least... someday.

i'm not sure how attempting to motivate myself would turn out.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: Sinfire Titan on July 18, 2016, 11:58:32 PM
Just throwing this out there: Legacy items can grant Metamagic/Metapsionic feat effects ala metamagic rods. There are multiple different effects, and there's no upwards limit on how many Legacy items you can have at one time, so founding multiple legacies for free metamagic is plausible (just highly likely to get turned down by the DM).
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: PlzBreakMyCampaign on August 12, 2016, 03:39:22 PM
Just throwing this out there: Legacy items can grant Metamagic/Metapsionic feat effects ala metamagic rods. There are multiple different effects, and there's no upwards limit on how many Legacy items you can have at one time, so founding multiple legacies for free metamagic is plausible (just highly likely to get turned down by the DM).
FWIW, I see DMs use a 'one at a time' rule per each type of x.

It solves things like nightsticks and 500 feats. Since WoL also includes armors, though, presumably you should be able to have an armor of legacy and a weapon of legacy at the same time. The hp/spell slot penalties would stack though :(
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on November 22, 2017, 02:32:19 PM
Finished through post #23.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: snakeman830 on November 22, 2017, 06:04:23 PM
You're still ignoring this:

2. The Precise weapon enhancement never references the Precise Shot feat in any way.  It merely removes the -4 penalty for shooting into melee.  It does NOT grant the benefit of Precise Shot, nor the feat itself, instead it gives an identical, numeric benefit.

You need to remove the Precise weapon quality from "items that grant benefits of a feat."  Move it to "Items that Otherwise Duplicate Effect of a Feat."  The weapon property says it does not stack with Precise Shot, but it does not, in any way, suggest you get Precise Shot or the benefits thereof.

All the weapon property does is remove a penalty that doesn't exist if you have Precise Shot.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on November 22, 2017, 08:21:42 PM
You're still ignoring this:

2. The Precise weapon enhancement never references the Precise Shot feat in any way.  It merely removes the -4 penalty for shooting into melee.  It does NOT grant the benefit of Precise Shot, nor the feat itself, instead it gives an identical, numeric benefit.

You need to remove the Precise weapon quality from "items that grant benefits of a feat."  Move it to "Items that Otherwise Duplicate Effect of a Feat."  The weapon property says it does not stack with Precise Shot, but it does not, in any way, suggest you get Precise Shot or the benefits thereof.

All the weapon property does is remove a penalty that doesn't exist if you have Precise Shot.

Not intentional! Thank you for reminding me. =D

***

Updated... how's that?
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: snakeman830 on November 22, 2017, 09:53:55 PM
Perfect!
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on June 23, 2020, 09:31:16 PM
Updated through post #29.
Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: kitep on January 28, 2022, 02:21:23 AM
Bracers of Arcane Freedom - MIC, p80
 - Still Spell feat, 2x/day, 2300gp

Title: Re: Handbook of the Exotic Practice of Feat Binding Discussion thread
Post by: nijineko on February 01, 2022, 08:55:12 PM
Thank you!