The [list] tag normally works with both [li][/li] and with [*]. However, for some weird reason, it seems like the [*] version just does not work in
one thread. It works just fine elsewhere on the boards. Even weirder, it seems as though it would work fine in subsequent posts in the same thread (using Reply and then using the same thing that works everywhere else appears fin in the preview, but not when modifying the original post).
I... I got no idea what could possibly be causing this. Heck, even some of my older posts have lists with [*] and they're working just fine. My bets guess is that some developer decided to troll the consumers by having a random post in each installation break a random BBCode (but I have my doubts about that).
Edit: To be clear, [li] does work, so I can still make lists, it's just less convenient.