I thought the range penalty was -2 for each increment beyond the first? Just for future reference.
Uh... yeah, that's what I meant. [Sure I did...]
Troll is 40 feet away, so that would be 3 increments beyond the first, or –6. Sorry 'bout that.
... Well, technically, at 10 feet you suffer the penalty, too, and at 40 it would be –8, but I don't think anyone ever actually plays it that way, because then it's impossible to use a dagger thrown without either taking a penalty, or suffering an AoO. So, technically
I was right, but I would never actually play it that way
I treat range increments as inclusive of the last square, not exclusive of the last square (which, though RAW, is dumb). So yeah, it would have been –6.
Yeah, the extra hands adding Str damage is all good.
And that d20 roll is just waiting for the inevitable charge...