Executive Decision Time
I have removed 3.5 as an option. It was the most voted for, but I've decided that I want to do something different from what 99% of the PbP games on this board are.
At the other end of things, I have also removed Starfinder. The adventure paths I've looked at are extremely combat heavy and I think that learning a new system plus running my first PbP plus having that first PbP be super combat heavy which can slow the PbP down significantly is just too much for me. Maybe once I know the system better and am more comfortable running a game on the board.
Current voting for remaining systems is as follows:
5th: Strat, Raineh, Versatility_Nut
PF: oslecamo, Raineh, linklord
Savage Worlds: SorO, Strat, linklord
If it would help people figure out what they are interested in, I can narrow each system down to a basic campaign description once I get home from work.
In addition, each game would start at first level (or the Savage Worlds equivalent).