1
Handbook Discussion / Re: Ghost Guide Ghoulishness - Discuss at will
« on: January 11, 2012, 02:10:44 AM »
Equipment+Handy Haversack: Good suggestion, and yay if it works! (Then again, this is exactly the sort of ad hoc rulings the DM needs to make. There's no rule that says you can - or can't - put a material object inside an ethereal extra-dimensional space, and what happens when you pull it out again. If a DM didn't allow that, I wouldn't hold it against him.)
Equipment+Plane Shift: The thing is, you normally need Wizard 13 or Cleric 9 to cast Plane Shift. For many builds this comes late, and for others it never comes at all.
There, Not There series: These are good links, they should go straight into the handbook, even if they are suggestions and not RAW. Btw, if I remember correctly, they say somewhere that the Ghost-Touch property shouldn't be abused, specifically the "when beneficial" part.
Anitmagic Field: Yes, you still exist on the ethereal plane, you only wink out of the material. You can't use any Su ability of course (abjurations extend to the ethereal).
Changing your creature type: OK, I'm not gonna argue RAW at all. I'm just saying, I wouldn't ask for such shenanigans as a player and I wouldn't allow it as a DM. Infinite Wishes are also RAW, but no one in his right mind plays like that, except for intentionally silly games. (Not that I'm comparing the two, I'm just saying.) A simple warning "this may not fly with your DM, but ask anyway" would suffice.
Equipment+Plane Shift: The thing is, you normally need Wizard 13 or Cleric 9 to cast Plane Shift. For many builds this comes late, and for others it never comes at all.
There, Not There series: These are good links, they should go straight into the handbook, even if they are suggestions and not RAW. Btw, if I remember correctly, they say somewhere that the Ghost-Touch property shouldn't be abused, specifically the "when beneficial" part.
Anitmagic Field: Yes, you still exist on the ethereal plane, you only wink out of the material. You can't use any Su ability of course (abjurations extend to the ethereal).
Changing your creature type: OK, I'm not gonna argue RAW at all. I'm just saying, I wouldn't ask for such shenanigans as a player and I wouldn't allow it as a DM. Infinite Wishes are also RAW, but no one in his right mind plays like that, except for intentionally silly games. (Not that I'm comparing the two, I'm just saying.) A simple warning "this may not fly with your DM, but ask anyway" would suffice.