1
Handbook Discussion / Re: Sha'ir Handbook: Semi-Phenomenal, Nearly-Cosmic Power - Discussion
« on: July 19, 2014, 05:49:58 PM »The Sha'ir has access to the spells of those domains, not the domains themselves. It recieves none of the other benefits of these domains.
Is "access" defined explicitly anywhere? Here's what I came up with:
Complete Champion: quoted above, nothing more about what "access" means
PHB just says that says that choosing a domain grants you access to the domain's spells and granted power.
Quote from: Complete Divine (p.20)
"If a noncleric enters a prestige class that allows access to a domain, the character still gains access to the domain."
No help there. Access is access... OK, let's check a newer source.
Quote from: Rules Compendium p. 85
A domain spell is on a user’s spell list only if the user has access to that domain.
So, does the Sha'ir have Domain spells on its spell list? Yes.
Does it therefore have access to those domains? I would argue that it does.
Again, unless you have more explicity-defined "access?"
And if you were arguing that the wording of the Sha'ir ability prohibits it, I'm not so sure about that either.
Quote from: Dragon Compendium p.53
..he gains no other benefit of the cleric class, including the granted powers of these domains.emphasis mine, obviously. But according to CC, we don't need to be a cleric, so that makes no nevermind.