hmm ... tangent ...
What if in the middle of the Prime Material plane,
you had a small piece of the Plane Of Dust,
(brought in by say the PrC in Manual Of The Planes)
and you cast/-fest Anti-Genesis on it.
The Dust-Plane part turns to "dust" but it is
not the exact same kind of dust. It's kinda like an Anti-Plane.
Same thing with Earth or Negative Energy.
The opposite of Earth is Air, but this turns into dust.
Negative gets turned into the dust, even though Earth had nothing to do with it.
Dust-Plane is Earth
plus Negative.
Earth gets turned into the dust.
Dust gets turned into the dust.
Negative gets turned into the dust.
Soo ...
Anti-Plane ...
This seems to be a new type of substance.