all-homebrew game?

[sirpercival]

Lol my gestalt suggestion was not serious, just an expression of frustration.

Let's do this.  I'll either submit a Warpsoul/Soulfused Transcendant, OR (if I end up using the previous combo in Tshern's game) a Gerudo.

[Quillwraith]

Hey Quill, I assume I can't play a Magipunk class?

You can. Most of them seem like they could be adapted to work outside the magipunk setting fairly easily.

No gestalt, it seems.

Oslecamo, littha, I'll look at those builds later today.

[sirpercival]

Hey Quill, I assume I can't play a Magipunk class?

You can. Most of them seem like they could be adapted to work outside the magipunk setting fairly easily.

Oh.  Oh, oh, oh.  Well then.  Things just got both simpler and more complicated

EDIT: Relevant questions, Quill.

1) What level of optimization are you comfortable with?
2) How do you feel about LA buyoff and bloodlines?

[Harald]

right.  the Dragonheart Adept is a bit too feral for what I wanted to do. I'm tempted between :
- A Sublime Shaper using Eternal Moment & Fleeting Image as Circles, Ironheart Surge & Shadow Hand as disciplines.
- A Flamespeaker, because there is nothing you can't solve with fire. Perhaps a Pixie to make a new version of Carnivore's Hottest little Hottie. Fleeting Image, then Eternal Moment or Screeching Roc, and don't know yet for the last one.

[samnemath]

Lets see. What about
- a sublime shaper (thinking Unseen Impetus, Blustering gale combined with shadow hand, thrashing dragon or tigerclaw disciplines)
- or maybe a dementist http://www.minmaxboards.com/index.php?topic=1230 (sort of cthulhulean pokemon master)

[sirpercival]

Dementists are awesome -- I can tell you this from experience.

EDIT: I think I'll go with a Crystal Mage / Ritual Mage.  Just to up the homebrew awesomeness.

[Harald]

Dementists are indeed excellent, having seen one in action. Samnemath, if you want to go Sublime Shaper, then I'll go Flamespeaker.

(click to show/hide)

Let's bring the heat.

[samnemath]

Just a question Quillwraith. If I go with Dementist, what kind of creatures do I start with? Specific ones or whatever I want under a certain CR.

Since we are posting images 

Dementist with Dementia Creature

(click to show/hide)

Same Dementist using Insane Form

(click to show/hide)

[sirpercival]

Stolen from my Crystal Mage thread:

(click to show/hide)

[Quillwraith]

Oslecamo, yuan-ti and ghaele are both okay.

Littha, spellblade duelist is in.

1) What level of optimization are you comfortable with?
2) How do you feel about LA buyoff and bloodlines?

1: Some, but nothing like Ransom or Tyorre.
2: Bloodlines, but no LA buyoff.

Where are Flamespeaker and Sublime Shaper?

Just a question Quillwraith. If I go with Dementist, what kind of creatures do I start with? Specific ones or whatever I want under a certain CR.

If having come across it makes sense with your backstory and you could make the imprinting check, it's probably fine.

Stolen from my Crystal Mage thread:

(click to show/hide)

Yeah, Steve Argyle is quite good.

[Ziegander]

My plan for this game is to find some Tier 4-ish homebrew melee class, but then beef it up with the feats found HERE. Would that be okay, Quill?

[Harald]

Where are Flamespeaker and Sublime Shaper?

Right here and here

[sirpercival]

Crap.  Crystal Mage is too interesting 1-20 for me to go into Ritual Mage.

Gaaaaah.  Leadership!  Lol.  With a Thaumaturge/Ritual Mage.

BTW, don't worry -- I would never play Ransom in a game not specifically designed to accommodate monstrosities like him.  I'll keep it to a medium-high level of charop.

How do you feel about Dragon Mag material?

[Quillwraith]

I don't have any Dragon Mag.

[oslecamo]

Thanks! I'll make an angel gish then.

So, was the actual level decided? Somebody last page sugested lv8, that sounds good to me.

[Quillwraith]

Thanks! I'll make an angel gish then.

So, was the actual level decided? Somebody last page sugested lv8, that sounds good to me.

No-one's disagreed with level 8 yet, but we must see what everyone thinks.

I'd like to take a look at backstories, if you(plural) have them yet, so that I can try to figure out how things will start.

My plan for this game is to find some Tier 4-ish homebrew melee class, but then beef it up with the feats found HERE. Would that be okay, Quill?

Yah.

Many things you(plural) have mentioned give me ideas for NPCs. (I might use core classes for NPCs, 'cause there's the prewritten characters, but for major ones I intend to also use only homebrew.)

[Harald]

8 is good. BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD GOD ! herm. sorry.

[oslecamo]

I'd like to take a look at backstories, if you(plural) have them yet, so that I can try to figure out how things will start.

Well, it would greatly help us if we had an idea of how the campaign setting is. You mentioned something about a custom setting on the first page.

[Ziegander]

Oh, gawd. A homebrew setting? May I suggest The Vorpal Tribble's lovely A Dying Ember setting?

EDIT: Also, how would you feel about allowing THESE two-weapon fighting rules to apply to this homebrew game (along with the feats found there)?

Also, are you okay with THIS fighter rewrite combined with THESE FEATS?

[Quillwraith]

Well, it would greatly help us if we had an idea of how the campaign setting is. You mentioned something about a custom setting on the first page.

I kinda forgot that for a bit...
It's rather hard to get the idea into writing in a form that would make sense to anyone else. I'll work on it.

Oh, gawd. A homebrew setting? May I suggest The Vorpal Tribble's lovely A Dying Ember setting?

EDIT: Also, how would you feel about allowing THESE two-weapon fighting rules to apply to this homebrew game (along with the feats found there)?

Also, are you okay with THIS fighter rewrite combined with THESE FEATS?

Dying Ember...
I am Impressed. I had a different setting in mind though.

TWF variant is cool unless it causes problems for someone else, your fighter one also(but don't abuse leadership please), the other two are fine.