"I need to level up" (said an hour in to the session -- in regards to XP from last session, immediately after f'n initiative had been rolled)
dafuq?!
"That's what your Mom said."
"Sometimes, even an adventurer needs a backrub."
"Let me think... What would Snooky do in this situation?""You said giant rat? I thought you said giant 'cat'.""Can my elf have a Ring of Power like in Lord of the Rings?""Can I play the bad guy!!""Can I play an ugly half-orc chick named 'Rosanne'?""Which one is the 6-sided dice again?"